Milk Paint And Plaster Paint Technqiue
Milk paint and plaster paint technique happened by accident. A similare accident happened when I discovered that you can distress furniture using vinegar. You can read about that HERE.
I was searching for a mantel for quite some time now. Hoping that I’d score a beautiful vintage mantel with perfect chippy patina. I found a few. But they were either out of my price range or not the right size. This was my price range and it was the right size. The only thing that was totally off was that this was new and not vintage.
I knew that I could totally fix that with a little paint. I decided to use milk paint because I knew that I’d get a great chippy patina using it. I used Miss Mustard Seed’s milk paint in ironstone. I added two coats of ironstone, and I noticed that it was chipping off really well. Like almost too much of the paint was chipping off. That’s not a good thing!
Instead of panicking I decided to step back, take a deep breath and re-evaluate it.
Then I decided to add my home made plaster paint to the mantel. I used this because I was totally out of my paint. I will admit that this plaster paint is supposed to mimic chalky paint, but it doesn’t work as well as the real deal.
I didn’t even finish scraping this piece, I left it as it was. I know you’re probably wondering why. Well, I wanted to use all of that texture that was already on this piece to create an authentic chippy patina.
Once I started painting this piece, I could see how all of those chippy pieces and loose paint was creating an amazing chippy patina! I was loving how this was looking.
I added two coats of my homemade plaster paint, then once it was dry I added a coat of dark wax on top to bring out more of the chippy texture.
Using both of these paints really made this piece look authentically old. Doesn’t this look amazing?
Here’s a tip for you. When your trying to make a piece look old and chippy, don’t try to be perfect just go with it. Mistakes may happen. And it this case, this was the best mistake that could have happened.
I think that’s why I love working with milk paint. It’s very unpredictable. You may get a perfectly smooth finish and sometimes you won’t. This mantel had a super smooth finish on it. I think that’s why the paint didn’t adhere.
I think one mistake I see others make when they try to create an aged patina on a piece is that they worry about perfection. With older pieces there are no perfections. Look at old pieces of furniture and study the imperfections that they have.
Here is one more look at the before.
And the after.
I challenge you to be open and creative when you’re painting and creating a chippy patina.
Rosemary says
Love it, Anne. Great job!
Anne says
Thank you Rosemary!As I was doing this project I thought of you 🙂
debbiedoos says
Looks beautiful Anne. I also love your new scale. Very unique!
Anne says
Thank you Debbie!
Pam Ballard says
Wow amazing. I sometimes forget to see the finished product after a coat of paing on something. This inspires me to look for some furniture and do a redo! Love your mantle, love your scale, love your blog. Have a wonderful day! Thanks for sharing.
Anne says
Thanks so much Pam!
Maryann says
I love it too! It’s great that you can move it around when you feel like it. Great job and love the finish. take care, Maryann
Anne says
Thank you Maryann!
Vickie says
You did such a good job on your new mantel that I would be convinced it was vintage if I saw it at an antique shop! Well done, Anne! You are going to love accessorizing your new “old” mantel!
Anne says
Thank you Vickie and yes I will 🙂
Rondell says
Amazing paint job and it came out great…it looks like it was painted like that in the first place! Great price on the mantle too!
Anne says
Thank you Rondell!
Kim says
Wow, Anne, what a price and you made it fabulous!!
Anne says
Thank you Kim!
lynn at shabby story says
what a find! that is such a great deal! and i love the finish, anne:)
Anne says
Thank you Lynn!
Gee says
It looks great Anne. The price… perfection. 🙂
Anne says
Thank you Gee!
laurie says
Utterly fabulous, Anne!!!! I LUV all the worn chippiness and imperfections!!!! I’ve read that if the furniture piece has some sort of veneer or a lacquer coating on it, that milk paint will chip and flake to a greater degree. But that said….I think it makes the piece even more perfect! GREAT job, girlie!!!!!
xoxo laurie
Anne says
Thank you Laurie.Yes this piece had a pretty slick veneer,which is good and bad.Good because it will chip off,bad because sometimes it will chip a little more thank you want it to.
Michele/Finch Rest says
BRAVO!!!!!! Very well done, oh my what a neat way that all worked out for you, whoo hoo!!!!
It looks GREAT in that space, too. Love it.
Anne says
Thank you so much Michele!
Kris says
Wonderful Anne. This came out so beautiful. Great job.
Kris
Anne says
Thank you Kris!
Sandy brown says
I love how this turned out! You did a great job. I like how you call home made chalk paint plaster paint–good way to describe it. Thanks for sharing your beautiful mantle!
Anne says
Thank you Sandy,well that is what it is plaster mixed in latex paint = plaster paint 🙂
Becky says
Oh Anne! It looks absolutely perfect!!! What an amazing job you did on it!! You could make tons of money doing this again and again to sell!! What an awesome technique. People would be hard pressed to believe it wasn’t old.
Thanks so much for sharing!
Have a lovely week!
Becky
Anne says
Thank you Becky!
Jasper's Cottage says
That turned out so beautiful, I love it! I am so inspired to try painting something right now even though it would be my first time. Thanks! xo Jonni xo
Anne says
Thank you Jonni!
Vanessa says
Hi Anne,
I just found your wonderful site and already bookmarked it. (Yes, I know I’m a little behind the times. I was a late bloomer.) However, I’m enjoying a pot of tea and reading all you previous posts. You are one talented lady !!!!
Your mantle is the perfect blend of chippy, old and most of all imperfect. What an amazing score for only $38.00 !!!!!!!! I’m never that lucky.
Thank you for sharing your talents with us,
Vanessa
Anne says
Thank you so much Vanessa!
kelly says
I really love your new mantel! It looks so good now that you’ve painted it. I never would’ve guessed that it was once a dark stained looking wood.
Anne says
Thank you Kelly, it’s the power of paint 🙂
revi says
LOVE the textural finish you got, Anne. 🙂 Your mantel is beautiful.
Anne says
Thank you Revi!
Tammy says
oh is this beautiful….Love it!
Anne says
Thank you Tammy!
Jeanine says
Beautiful Perfection!
Anne says
Thanks so much Jeanine!
Christine says
what a fabulous transition!!! Great job!!! Christine from Little Brags
Anne says
Thank you Christine!
Gail says
Oh Anne, that is gorgeous!! I LOVE it!! What an inspiration this beautiful mantel of yours is to me. Charlie and I made one and after seeing yours…..I’m re-doing mine for my dining room. I’m pinning!! Hugs, Gail
Anne says
Thank you Gail!
Lisa @ Fern Creek Cottage says
It truly looks like a vintage piece that was a painted many years ago! It is beautiful Anne!
Anne says
Thank you Lisa!
Cheryl Jasso says
You are amazing. I don’t know how you find the time to do all you do. How many hours would you estimate you spent on the mantle? It amazes me how you spot something, bring it home, and, bam, you make it how you want it.
Anne says
Thank you Cheryl.I probably spent 4 or 5 hours working on this,which really is not bad.Yep if I can dream it I can do it 🙂
Suzan says
Oh Anne – what a find – and what a transformation – beautiful beautiful makeover!
XOX
Anne says
Thank you Suzan!
Melanie says
Oh my goodness Anne…it turned out absolutely beautiful! It looks just like a really old piece would look, with all of the character and history we all love. Just perfect!
Anne says
Thank you Melanie!
Joanne Boulter says
Anne you always do such a tremendous job. It look’s great.
Anne says
Thank you Joanne!
Jeanette @ Creating a Life says
What a great find, Anne! Great job giving it the look you wanted. So pretty!
Jeanette
Anne says
Thank you Jeanette!
lynn cockrell says
The mantel makeover is wonderful, Anne! A beautiful transformation!
Anne says
Thank you so much Lynn!
Katie Mansfield says
That was an amazing deal. I love the painted finish too. You did a great job! You will have so much fun decorating that for the holidays and seasons.
Anne says
Thank you Katie,yes it was!
Christine says
That’s just beautiful. Once again, it shows how a new life can be created for an old piece.
I discovered the ultimate way to get an authentic chippy look. Leave your stuff, in my case antique doors, in the front yard for a year.
Yup. In the yard.
However, my authentic chippy finish is so chippy, I’m not certain how to glue it back down without being lumpy and weird. So I’m having the same trouble as you! I’m thinking of letting it all chip off, bringing it back to bare wood. Then I’ll put it in the yard again and get [wait for it] weathered wood! 🙂
But I think you’ve given me wonderful ideas. Thank you so much for sharing this transformation.
Love reading you!
Anne says
Thank you so much Christine! Yes that is the best place to get an authentic chippy piece for sure.
Manon Duguay says
Hi! I would like to know the quantities of plaster,water and latex paint you used for your fireplace mantel and ist it plaster paris.thanks!
Ruth van Aalst says
Wow Anne beautiful!! MMSMP is indeed perfect for a chippy look Always look at your video’s and still love it.
Thank you for your tips.
Best regards from the Netherlands.
Ruth.